Why holders should earn: the case for revenue-sharing auctions

Every other outbid board takes your bid and keeps it. TopBidder pools it and pays it back. Here is why that is the future of the format.

The first wave of outbid boards had one thing in common: your bid left and never came back. Pay to rank, fund the operator's next tweet, repeat. Several say it outright in their pitch: no revenue sharing.

That is a bug, not a feature. Here is the problem it creates: if bids are pure cost, the only people who rationally bid are those with marketing budgets to burn. The board becomes an ad network with better aesthetics — and the community that made it fun (the small projects, the indie hackers, the personal brands) gets priced out of its own spectacle.

Revenue sharing fixes the incentive. On TopBidder, stakes fund a prize pool. Holders accrue earnings from that pool while their spot stays ranked, and withdrawals settle on-chain in USDC. Your bid is not a donation to the operator's runway — it is a position in a market that pays its participants.

What this changes in practice:

The board prices attention honestly. When holders earn from the pool, a rank has yield, not just vanity. That yield shows up in how people bid: fewer emotional spikes, more positions held deliberately.

Holders become evangelists. The people on the board are the people earning from it, so the people most motivated to bring spectators are the ones holding positions. Growth compounds through the participants instead of through an ad budget.

The operator's incentive stays aligned. The operator earns from the spread between what the pool pays out and what the board takes in — which means the operator profits most when the board is healthy, the spectators keep coming, and holders keep earning. A pure-auction operator profits identically whether or not anyone ever benefits.

Crypto made this possible technically — on-chain payments, verifiable pools, wallets as accounts. TopBidder's bet is that it matters culturally too: the next generation of attention markets will be ones where the audience and the advertisers are the same people, and the money stays in the game.

All essays · Put your product on the board → · Next: How to claim your first spot on TopBidder